The Outsourcing Blog..."Horses for Sources"

Captive sell-offs: good for innovation, good for employment

I know I've been depressing everyone with calls for change and for our flagging companies to step up and disrupt their business models.  But did I ever say I was here to make you happy?

However, one shimmer of light amidst this gloom is the increase in activity of service providers buying up business' captives or shared service operations (often under the guise of a new "client win"). 

EXL's acquisition of Schenider Logistics' Czech operations is yet another recent example of a service provider making a strategic move to add scale and expertise to its delivery portfolio.  In this case, EXL is cementing its European presence in a unique and attractive sourcing location, enhancing its F&A BPO business and bolstering its multilingual capabilities, in addition to incorporating supply chain and logistics management process expertise - an area of increasing importance in the industry.

So why is this good for industry?

Being Frank about Global Sourcing: An interview with Cognizant's CEO (Part II)

Since Part I of the Francisco D'Souza interview, I've been assured Frank has improved his golf handicap. Now he'll discuss his views on how ITO service providers can differentiate themselves, the convergence of IT and BPO solutions... and a few other tidbits...

PF: How can ITO providers differentiate themselves in today’s market? Is it by vertical focus, or other elements?

FD: Given the extraordinary pressure that clients are under, I think that the key to differentiation is to focus on how to make clients’ businesses stronger. Rather than focusing on technology, process or methodology, I think providers need to really understand a client’s business drivers and then sell and deliver solutions that further those business objectives. As I said before, clients are facing both cyclical and secular pressures. As a result, depending on the client, their objectives of outsourcing will be very different. Some clients seek to improve efficiency or effectiveness. Others are looking to use outsourcing as a enabler of innovation. Still others are looking at outsourcing as a tool to gain access to the best talent in the world – regardless of where that talent is located. And of course, given the significant secular changes we are seeing, many clients are looking to outsource as a way to enable agility and transformation within the organization.

Can 6-sigma really help execute an effective sourcing process?

One major service provider that has quietly - and very effectively - grown its US presence over the last couple of years is HCL.  And behind the scenes is a very classy guy, Debashish Sinha, who pulls the strings across its US sales, marketing and operations units. 

Anyone dealing with HCL these days is always glad to have Debashish around (despite the fact he organized their last industry event in Orlando).  Prior to HCL, Deb has consulted for both Conscient Partners and NeoIT, in addition to being Gartner Group's principle analyst for IT services and sourcing.  And when he's not comparing the subtle nuances of Malbecs or flying planes (not simultaneously, I assure you), he has some excellent views on the effectiveness of 6-sigma methodology in a sourcing environment.  Over to you Deb...

About four hundred years ago, Galileo Galilei noted that “We must measure what can be measured, and make measurable what cannot be measured,” a philosophy now embodied in the well-tested axiom “You can’t manage what you can’t measure”.

So how about managing the Sourcing cycle? How do you actually measure Risk, or Internal Readiness, or even effective Governance?

One potential option could be to use Planning for Six Sigma tools to “make measurable what can’t be measured”. After all, it’s still one of the most prominent approaches for managing by measurement.

The Kraft of Outsourcing: Learnings from Lee Coulter (Part III)

And finally… the last tranche of our three-part interview with Kraft’s Lee Coulter. Here’s Lee’s take on attributes service providers need to demonstrate, and some advice for budding sourcing executives today…

PF: Lee, when evaluating outsourcing service providers today, what attributes should companies look for? What should they try to avoid?

LC: That is a really big question and not one I am sure I can answer in less than ten pages. Every engagement is different, and the basic dimensions of suitability are: service scope, service quality, service cost, cultural match, the leadership teams, partnership capability, and risk. Assuming that you have providers capable of doing the job and meeting the objectives, then it is about the team and the commitment to true partnership (a topic for another day). These two things lead to a measure I use… confidence. So you would score the providers

Talent Management vs. HRO – it’s not an “either or” proposition

If you've ever ventured into the brave world of HR Outsourcing (and you need to be brave...) the chances are you'll hear the views of Ceridian's Keith Strodtman. 

Keith has been a constant at the global $1.6 billion HR services and store-card solutions giant for many years now, and when he's not coaching his twin girls' fastpitch softball team (that's "rounders" for any Brits on here), he's been running Ceridian's global HRO practice.  He is also widely recognized as HRO's smoothest man, with a constant smile, never a raised word, and never a hair out of place. 

Keith has some excellent views on how companies can use third-party managed services to take on their administrative work and focus their HR executives on what they should be doing:  helping develop their organizations' talent.  Over you Keith...

I’m not sure about you, but I don’t get why some analysts and bloggers

Wipro and Oracle partner to blow-up the BPO delivery model

Folks - I can exclusively reveal to you today that Wipro BPO and Oracle are shortly going to announce a partnership dubbed "simPlify", whereby Wipro will deliver PeopleSoft HR to both mid-market and high-end clients via a hosted utility BPO service, that will cater for 20 major countries.  They will also partner with The Hackett Group as part of the arrangement to provide performance benchmarks for HR processes.

The mid-market play is a true move towards "one-to-many", whereas the enterprise play will be a more customized approach.  Clients will need to invest

Contemplating the BPO industry with Wipro's Ashutosh Vaidya

One of the most enthusiastic leaders in the BPO industry is the man who has overseen Wipro's rapid rise in recent times:  Ashutosh Vaidya.  In-between playing squash, watching cricket and clocking up a ridiculous quantity of airmiles, Ashutosh has overseen a series of Finance & Accounting, HR and supplier management wins that have moved the service provider into the BPO industry's top tier.  I asked Ashutosh to share his views of the current state of the BPO industry and what steps need to be take to ensure the continual growth of the business in these times.

PF: Ashutosh, we’ve been through a tremendous development in the world of BPO over the last decade. What, in your opinion, has worked, and what hasn’t?

AV: Indeed the BPO world has come a very long way over the past decade. In fact, 2009 really marks the 10th anniversary of the meaningful 3rd party BPO

Phil Fersht on service provider rankings: make the experts accountable, not faceless brands

Vinnie Mirchandani has his latest take on the constant controversy of third-party researchers, consultants and associations compiling rankings of service providers.  This time the IAOP's Global Services 100 is being questioned. 

We've also had some banter about the Black Book of Outsourcing on this site, which made such a noise with its constant rankings of service providers, that Datamonitor decided to buy them to hop on this bandwagon.  And we've never even got to discussing the Global Services 100, or several other rankings that come out periodically.  Moreover, some "analyst" firms make a living ranking service providers, while barely bothering to talk to their customers, and selling white papers to the winners so they can flout their success (you all know who you are).

Personally, as an analyst and advisor, I find these lists useful - I sometimes find out about some provider I didn't know a lot about, and they draw attention to who's doing well at the

Contemplating the BPO industry with Infosys' Ritesh Idnani

When he's not tinkering with his fast-cars and rock music, Ritesh Idnani has emerged one of the key guys behind Infosys' prominent rise as a leading BPO provider.  But's it's not been an easy ride...when you get up close, you can start to see some grey hairs creeping in to defy those baby-face looks.  I've known Ritesh for a number of years and thought it ample time for him to share his views on the development of the BPO industry and what holds for the future in these crazy times...

PF: We've been through a tremendous development in the world of BPO over the last decade. What, in your opinion, has worked, and what hasn't?

RI: The emergence of outsourcing is not a new phenomenon. It has been practiced by corporates from the 60’s, but it is only in the last decade or so that corporations have recognized the phenomenon and actively engaging in outsourcing as a lever to reduce the effect of non-core activities contributing to the wrong side of P&L .

Keeping it onshore: an interview with Mark Vengroff

Having witnessed the rampant growth of Finance and Accounting BPO over recent years, the common thread among the leading service providers has been cost-arbitrage through offshore labor.  There is, however, one exception:  Vengroff Williams and Associates (VWA). 

Naturally, the core differentiators among service providers is the ability to innovate with process and technology, and provide great people to service their clients, however, the offshore element has created the cost-lever to entice companies to move into a BPO end-state.  VWA is the one service provider which has resisted the lure of offshore/nearshore delivery to drive down costs even further, and has chosen to focus on its onshore delivery centers underpinned by its order-to-cash technology solution to service its clients. 

VWA achieved a 5% share of F&A BPO engagements in 2007, which was greater than several of the leading BPO providers in the market, and boasts some blue-chip brands in its client portfoilio, namely Ford Motor Company, Federal Express, Kodak, Microsoft, Yamaha and others.  Moreover, in this age of protectionism, in addition to the increased focus on healthcare reform, you have to consider VWA in a unique position in the industry today.  I recently caught up with CEO Mark Vengroff to ask him to share with us the reasons for VWA's success.

Outsourcing is not for wimps

Many Americans in the global sourcing industry will attest that they never did quite separate themselves from their old colonial masters (but we let them think they did…). One such example has been the UK’s very own David Poole, imported by European outsourcing giant Capgemini to spearhead its Americas BPO business. Upon his arrival at these shores two years’ ago, David even adorned the title “Deputy”, in the hope he could quickly assimilate himself with the Wild West, installing himself and his family in Chicago, where he could steer them of clear of crime and corruption.

David, today,David has firmly established himself as a veteran of the BPO industry, leading Capgemini to some major new global F&A BPO client wins that have firmly established the firm’s global delivery footprint across the Americas, Europe and Asia (including major operations in China and India). He joined Capgemini in 2004, from PwC in London where he was a partner and a founding member of the firm’s global BPO business prior to IBM acquiring their operations. He’s made a significant contribution to the development of the global BPO industry, helping to craft several major global engagements since the early ‘90s. David is also a qualified management accountant and can wax-lyrical for hours about operational excellence with invoice processing. Enough said – over you Deputy Poole for your take on what outsourcing means to businesses today…

Outsourcing is not for wimps

I spend a lot of time talking about why outsourcing is a smart idea – I talk to clients, at public forums, in meetings, to my staff, heck I’ve even bent the ear of my dog on occasion. So, when Phil asked for volunteers to contribute to this blog, I naturally jumped on the soapbox. I couldn’t resist another chance to make my case, which is this: When the going gets tough, the tough outsource.

Where should outsourcing vendors invest their marketing dollars in this climate?

Being an analyst, you get a broad view of all the entities competing for the same service provider dollar. You also get a good perspective on how service providers can get the best bang for their marketing buck. And being a blogger, you also pick up a strong sense for the effectiveness of media outreach, but I'll save that discussion for another time.

There is no one-stop support shop for vendors to find and attract new clients, and influence the market - they need to gauge where they need to build influence, using both direct tactical measures - i.e. speaking at conferences or advertising, and indirect measures - i.e. influencing influencers or subliminal branding. The current pull-back in discretionary spending from vendor marketing budgets is seriously exposing the bloated array of firms feeding off the vendor marketing-dime, and with a lot less to go round, we're going to see some firms exit the market, some market consolidation, and others simply going out of business. We'll also see some boutiques linger around the industry because their owner has no idea what else to do, and his only costs are living and travel expenses, and maintaining a website.  Desperate times call for desperate behavior and none more so than for many of those entities forging their living selling to IT services and BPO firms.

Is the call center finally coming back onshore?

We had a great discussion a few weeks' ago regarding the USA's potential to take on more sourcing work, with increasing unemployment and downward wage pressures.  I've made this point a few times now, but BPO is clearly the bigger onshore opportunity than mainstream application services for the US to muscle in on sourcing work.  And where better to start than the call center?

Bottom-line, President Obama should take a leaf out of Margaret Thatcher's book and examine simple effective ways to provide productive and sustainable employment in depressed areas where industry is in a terminable decline.  I never voted for old Maggie, but she did do one very smart thing during her tenure as British PM - she closed down unprofitable coalmines during the 80's recession, and encouraged businesses to set up call centers in depressed British cities.  Now there are over 650,000 call center employees across the UK. 

NASSCOM: Pushing the Reset Button on an Industry, But Hush-Hush on Satyam

We are priveleged this year to have AMR's own Dana Stiffler at the NASSCOM show in Mumbai.  What a time to be at the heart of the Indian services industry with the recent Mumbai terror events, the Satyam saga and the current economic crisis...  How is India Inc. responding? Over you to Dana:

NASSCOM President Som Mittal opened the group’s 17th annual leadership conference with praise for the resilient city of Mumbai, as the packed house observed a moment of silence for the victims of the city’s terrorist attacks last November. It’s a watershed moment for NASSCOM and the industry in general and Mr. Mittal struck just the right tone in his opening comments: cheerful, welcoming, resolute. Addressing the attacks and Satyam’s challenges up front, he told us it was time to reset expectations.

As for specifics, Mr. Mittal announced that NASSCOM will reconvene its ethics and governance committee. He also highlighted green technology

We are priveleged this year to have AMR's own Dana Stiffler at the NASSCOM show in Mumbai.  What a time to be at the heart of the Indian services industry with the recent Mumbai terror events, the Satyam saga and the current economic crisis...  How is India Inc. responding? Over you to Dana:

NASSCOM President Som Mittal opened the group’s 17th annual leadership conference with praise for the resilient city of Mumbai, as the packed house observed a moment of silence for the victims of the city’s terrorist attacks last November. It’s a watershed moment for NASSCOM and the industry in general and Mr. Mittal struck just the right tone in his opening comments: cheerful, welcoming, resolute. Addressing the attacks and Satyam’s challenges up front, he told us it was time to reset expectations.

As for specifics, Mr. Mittal announced that NASSCOM will reconvene its ethics and governance committee. He also highlighted green technology

BPO bucks the trend as WNS posts strong revenue growth

As we discussed last month, the Business Process Outsourcing market is maintaining double-digit growth as we move into 2009, fueled by increased uptake of source-to-pay, analytics, finance and accounting, HR and industry-specific services. WNS Global Services, one of the largest pure-play BPO providers, with revenues in excess of $500m, has posted a 15.9% increase in revenues for Q4 2008, over the corresponding quarter in the prior fiscal year.  WNS's main competitor Genpact is due to report on 18th February, and I would expect to see a similar revenue increase from them.  It really appears that BPO is finding its feet and

Alliance performs some spectacular Satyam ambulance-chasing

I was stupefied to observe Alliance Global Services, a privately-held IT services shop, join the Satyam ambulance-chasers by promoting it's "IT Partners Bill Of Rights".  Alliance is hoping to get 100,000 signatures supporting some version of its bill of rights and to have the document serve as a platform to establish a "global ethic consortium for IT services vendors":

1. The right to demand transparency throughout every step of an engagement -- from sales to contracting to delivery and termination
2. The right to fully understand the nature and character of an IT partner and the service that it provides to them
3. The right to fully understand the financial viability of an IT partner
4. The right to be made aware of any impending legal charges against an IT partner, should they arise, as soon as they occur
5. The right to arrive at a mutually agreed upon definition of the term "trusted partner"
6. The right to expect a clear contract that defines fees and expenses up front before any agreement is signed
7. The right to terminate a relationship with no financial penalty in the event of any admitted fraudulent activity
8. The right to demand the existence of a truly independent board of advisers
9. The right to expect the presence of an independent financial auditor accompanied by a set of checks and balances
10. The right to demand accountability for any actions taken within the scope of a technology project or as part of a firm's broader business practices

While I cannot argue with any client requesting any of the above from an IT vendor (or any client of any services supplier in any industry for that matter), this media-marketing is shamelessly exploiting the Satyam situation to market its own services and take advantage of media-hounds hungry to add fuel to this controversy.  One vendor cooks the books and suddenly the whole world of offshore outsourcing is crooked? Would this action really have prevented Ramalinga Raju doing what he did?  Puh-lease!

Beware of Satyam ambulance-chasers

Been inundated with calls from several Satyam competitors circling their clients like vultures... read my thoughts over at Think Global.

Satyam: It was like riding a tiger, not knowing how to get off without being eaten

A great quote to cap a sad story for Satyam's Ramalinga Raju, who resigned as Chairman today. 

Following the recent issues regarding Satyam’s financial irregularities, India’s IT-BPO services industry finds itself under increased financial scrutiny from Wall St analysts and corporate clients. However, while Satyam has a major challenge ahead to maintain its market position, and is a likely takeover target, we do not believe this fiasco will have longer-term ramifications for the Indian services sector, as long as Satyam’s creative accounting turns out to be an isolated incident and not a more pervasive problem across the sector.

Satyam’s existing customers will ask questions, but are unlikely to switch suppliers, unless Satyam loses a large number of crucial operational staff in the coming weeks. However, Satyam is now at a disadvantage in winning new business in the short-term as it struggles to shake off the current controversy. Plus, some customers renewing existing agreements will be evaluating alternative service provider options, in the wake of the uncertainty surrounding Satyam’s future. Its new leadership needs to move fast to right the ship and placate corporate accounts, and likely prepare the firm for an imminent takeover – the firm’s stock just hit a new all-time low. With Satyam’s strength across software service areas, particularly high-margin enterprise application services – we believe potential suitors include

HRO is out of rehab

We've had many animated discussions in the past regarding the trials and tribulations of the HRO market. To cut to the chase, HRO has struggled to live up to expectations as clients struggled with poorly integrated service delivery, overly complex operational issues, the lack of common HR standards and common HR technology platforms. This often resulted in negligible cost savings and fractured service provider relationships.  Not to mention some significant write-downs by some of the providers who took on overly complex engagements.

However, new research I've been carrying out in recent weeks

Smarter and smaller: banks bank on BPO

I am delighted to introduce a long-time industry friend, and one of the pioneering executives in the world of financial services BPO:  Michael Koontz. 

Michael has spent most of his career (14 years, in fact) helping steer Wachovia's BPO strategy, where he led over 130 transitions, managed over 1000 SLAs, over four countries and three service providers.  He also served as Wachovia's CFO for Banking Operations.  Michael recently made his first foray into service provider world, leading the financial services vertical for up-and-coming BPO and KPO service provider Aditya Birla Minacs.  

Michael is sharing his views with us on where he sees the banking sector going with its BPO strategies - namely a further sell-off of captives, service provider rationalization, growth in regional markets, and also the smaller banks opening up to BPO contracts.  Over to you Michael:

    What we are seeing in the financial services sector is nothing less

Outsourcing: cash, growth and hedge-trimming

Spending the day with Accenture at their annual analyst presentation, it helped put a lot of our current predicament into perspective.

We can debate, for hours, the finer points of whether outsourcing is currently helping the wounded US economy, but what is abundantly clear, as Accenture’s CEO Bill Green points out, is the need for the US economy to be competitive globally – and to be competitive as a nation, we need our businesses to be competitive.

We also had the pleasure of listening to one of outsourcing’s legendary figures, Kevin Campbell, who runs Accenture’s $10bn outsourcing business. For those of you who don’t know Kevin, he was a pivotal figure behind the industry growth of HR outsourcing at Exult, before moving over to Accenture in 2005 post Hewitt’s acquisition. He is one of the industry’s most straight-talking and colorful characters, with a seemingly infinite supply of energy (evidenced by the 4.00AM emails he shoots off periodically).

Kevin makes some great points that outsourcing can – and is – providing many enterprises today with many more business benefits than simply slashing administrative costs. However, you need to engage a service partner which can deliver

Wipro brews Brazilian BPO

Wipro has continued its aggressive surge into the BPO world by announcing plans to open a BPO delivery center in Curtiba, Brazil, to service it new client, AmBev, the South American bewing giant, and subsidiary of global brewing giant InBev.  InBev recently had its merger with Anheuser-Busch approved to create a global beer monolith - not a bad industry to be developing your outsourcing business, in this economy (to quote a CIO at a major brewer recently: "we love the good times, but we REALLY LOVE the bad times"...)

Following on from Capgemini's agreement to take over Unilever's South American BPO operations, we are clearly seeing signs - as we discussed last year - that Latam countries have great potential for delivering BPO services, such as finance and accounting and HR, in addition to supporting IT engagements (particularly with the legacy development skills that have sprung out of the Latam financial services sector).  This latest development further augments the discussions that the leading outsourcing providers see Latam as a major addition to a global delivery framework, especially when you consider the investments Accenture, Genpact, IBM, Infosys, TCS and others have also been making in Latam resources.

Moreover, this announcement follows on from several major recent BPO wins from Wipro, which has been performing a stellar job taking on multi-tower BPO services for a number of global clients across finance, HR, customer care and some industry-specific domains.

Cash is king again as M&A activity in outsourcing hots up

We've been talking a lot about consolidation in the outsourcing industry and when/how/if it will happen.  We can debate for hours the strategic benefits of service providers of adding niche competences, industry specialization, process acumen and global scale, and whether they should merge, acquire captives, or grow organically through client acquisition to achieve this.  However, the financial crisis is creating a compelling event to accelerate M&A between service providers. 

The amount of consolidation we're seeing in the financial sector, which is likely to have knock-on effects into other industries, will drive new client needs for global sourcing models. Many clients are worried about making large initial capital investments in outsourcing engagements - especially ones which have complex transition and transformational needs, hence those service providers which can help streamline these costs over the course of a contract will be successful. Complexity, disruption and increased globalization drive change, and outsourcing is one vehicle that can help many companies reach a global support infrastructure quickly.  Hence, those service providers with the global scale, competency and financial resources to deliver this quickly will be the winners in this market.

While this industry has ramped-up beyond the wildest expectations over the last 5 years,

Blogging on the road again...

Washington D.C.this week:  I have the privilege of delivering a keynote address to Mercer's clients on the subject entitled "Creating a Strategic Enterprise Sourcing Strategy and Governing Change" (whatever will I think up next...).  I look forward to posting some banter from their conference, where the central theme is "Successfully Managing the Global Journey".  I am particularly interested to hear Jeff Miller and Juila Velixon discuss Mercer's recent study conducted with the Harvard Business School on global service delivery models.  I promise to share the findings here.  Am also looking forward to hearing Jason Averbrook (great blog by the way) attempting to tie together web 2.0, new HR technologies and outsourcing.  Big topics - I love it :)

San Francisco and New York next week: I am more excited than usual at the prospect of attending Oracle OpenWorld this year.  Both Oracle and SAP's signature events have fast taken-over as industry meets to anyone in the hi-tech and services businesses.  If you are there and want to meet up, drop me a mail.  What's exciting this year is the stage they are giving to BPO - come visit the panel discussion entitled the "The Good, The Bad and The Ugly", Moscone South, 307 at 5.30pm on Monday.  I'll be joined on the panel with my long-time industry cohorts Stan LePeak (Equaterra) and Mark Stelzner (Inflexion Advisors). I'll be spending the latter half of the week in Manhattan where I have brought together some of the leading minds in the BPO industry for a behind-closed-doors round-table (no vendors allowed...sorry).

London and India:  Am making plans to visit London and India later in November and December, so look forward to meeting up with many of you during my travels.

Poland: More than "just another" BPO location

I received a very interesting synopsis from a senior executive at one of the major global IT-BPO providers on the subject of Poland as an offshore delivery location.  From my own personal experience, Poland has proved to be a first-class location for high-quality, multi-lingual support, particularly for BPO functions such as finance and HR.  No wonder providers such as Accenture, ADP, Capgemini, Genpact, HCL, HP and IBM have all made significant investments there, in addition to many captive centers that have been established there in recent years. 

Siddhartha makes some excellent points, most notably that Poland is simply not an "alternative offshore location", as its value-proposition is not driven by scale and low-cost, but by highly-motivated and educated staff, and is a proven first-class hub for multi-lingual European language support. He also makes a bold assumption that Poland has the potential to be challenging the unique expertise of a country such as Israel, as Poland possesses far more potential that simply being a BPO / shared services location. In many instances, clients have not found significant cost savings using Polish delivery resources - they have used them because of the value and quality they bring to a global delivery model.  Over to you Siddhartha:

Bristol Myers double-bundles

Bristol Myres Squibb today joined a rare breed of enterprises which have bundled apps and business process to two suppliers across finance and HR towers, with the announcement today that Accenture has taken on a 10-year $550m engagement to take on the pharma giant's finance and accounting processes and related application development and management services.  This follows on from their recent $324m 10-year deal signed with IBM that covered Human Resources BPO and related applications services.

This strategy builds firmly on our recent discussion on bundling apps, and the related business processes supported by those apps, under a single supplier.  This deal is just the latest in a series of contracts where the buyer is clearly recognizing the synergies of tying together process design, knowledge transfer and governance across IT and operations "boundaries".  Bundled outsourcing is not the answer for everyone, but it can provide a major spur for some companies looking to shake-up their back office functions, provided the vendor can demonstrate the skills and business understanding to drive this agenda.  These "boundaries" shouldn't exist, and bundled BPO is one potential solution that can help eliminate them. (Much) more on this topic to follow...

Are vendors and advisors getting too cosy?

We completed our survey looking at the world of third-party sourcing advisors this week, with the high-level results being discussed by my friend Ed Nair, over at Global Services Media. 

One of the key takeways, which I wanted to share with you, is the importance of the sourcing advisor / vendor relationship.  Of the 114 advisors who completed their section of the study, almost half of them revealed they frequently get business through their relationships with vendors.  We always knew that vendors refer advisors in certain client instances, but not to this extent:

HP/EDS: a reverse-takeover to create a services giant, but what's the game-plan?

So HP’s $13.9Bn acquisition of EDS became official this week – the largest-ever merger between two IT and business services providers.  The merged services entity resembles a reverse-takeover of the combined services business, with all the management positions remaining in Plano, with the exception of application services.

Overall, there were few surprises in the deal-finalization announcement. However, the fact that there seems to be no initial definitive plans to integrate the businesses at a service/product level beyond the newly-outlined organization structure, gives me some cause for concern, especially considering the fact that HP/EDS has already had three months to draw up a merger-strategy.  We're operating in a market where crafting and developing a global delivery strategy quickly is critical.  We've seen far too many failures in recent years from services providers that have sat on their traditional revenue streams, while others have pushed aggressive services agendas to win over clients looking for vendors with new thinking and focus on driving innovation into engagements.

Weekend sourcing

I spent the last week in this popular BPO-delivery location for such providers as ADP, Ceridian and Convergys... any guesses where?

(I'll give you a clue - it's not El Paso)

The Sheriff puts some fizz back into Cap

Capgemini is making some waves in the world of F&A BPO this year, winning some major global engagements, one of which is likely to be down in Tampa.   Not a bad return from new Sheriff David Poole (he claims he is no longer a deputy).  I have gone on the record to describe the current climate as crucial for Capgemini to break heavily in the global F&A BPO business - and they seem to be doing just that in a highly-competitive market.  They will be pushing hard for the number 3 market share position in the F&A BPO market by year-end behind both Accenture and IBM, but leading the large pack of outsourcing vendors jostling for position.  

How to make your boss look good

I recently had the pleasure of meeting with Kulwinder Singh, who heads up marketing for SatyamBPO in Hyderabad. It's great to meet a marketing guy who generally get's it.  Check out how he placed a picture of Kishore Rao, SatyamBPO's Head of Quality, receiving a Six Sigma IQ Excellence Award on a giant billboard in New York's Times Square...

The TSA awards its HRO engagement to Lockheed Martin - an overreaction?

There's been a lot of noise in the market this week concerning the TSA's award or their HRO contract to Lockheed Martin.  While this is clearly a bold move into HRO for Lockheed, this isn't likely to prove a major loss for Accenture.  Why?

Process Optimization is the key to successful Procurement BPO

I was recently engaged in an excellent conversation witn Gianni Giacommelli, who leads marketing strategy for SAP's BPO division, on the way forward for the Procurement BPO market.  One of the aspects about SAP that has impressed me, is their strong view of BPO as a opportunity, as opposed to a threat, to their business.  Gianni's boss, Christain Baader, has performed an excellent job driving this strategy in recent years, and made his case-in-point last year where he discussed why technology is an important key to BPO-sustainaility.   BPO is all about driving common strandards that can help service providers leverage their service staff and technology applications across multiple clients in a utility model.  So what better opportunity is there to encourage enterprises to standardize on a common ERP archtecture than when they evaluate BPO opportunities for their business?  And it's not solely about BPO, it's also about globalization: the more global enterprises can encourage their country-level businesses to operate within a global process template for functions such as finance, HR, sales and procurement, the quicker they can access critical data to make global business decisions.  Without digressing further, I asked Gianni to summarize our conversation regarding the development of procurement BPO solutions, where many of the leverage points for cost savings are driven through process and platform optimization, and not solely labor arbitrage.  Over to you Gianni:

WNS enters the BPO big-time

So the long debated and much anticipated saga of the Aviva BOT (Build-Operate-Transfer) has finally been resolved, with WNS Global Services taking on a $1 billion contract to become the British insurance giant's BPO provider of choice for the next 8 years.  WNS will be assuming all of the current 24/7 Customer contact center work and some of EXL Service's F&A work, with the latter's contract remaining until 2012.  This contract follows a storming 2007 for WNS, where the Mumbai-headquartered firm has made significant inroads into both financial services and retail sectors, in addition to its already dominant position in the airline sector. 

Some key points

The Evolution of Captive and Outsourced delivery models for business processes: what is the right option for your company?

We are privileged to showcase the following incisive article from my good long-time friend Graham Russell, who leads Global Transaction Processing for pharma giant AstraZeneca.  Graham has been a long-established and respected authority on shared services and outsourcing for many years, and is one of a rare breed of executives who has had many years of experience managing both models.  I can't think of many other people in the industry more qualified than Graham to discuss the merits and shortcomings of both captive and outsourced delivery models.  Over to you Graham:

Birth of captives

Once upon a time, global and pan regional companies operated as a collection of single country businesses. Their back-office financial support was organized in the same way, with processes and systems being developed at a local level in each country. In the eighties, new global companies such as Microsoft entered the scene and were able to quickly organize their businesses and their back-office support services in a different manner since they were able to start with a clean sheet of paper, making them appear lean and nimble.

The emergence of the Indian suppliers in HRO: the answer to HRO's slowdown?

One of the most interesting discussion points I had on my recent visit to India was centered on the eagerness of some of the India providers to infiltrate the HRO market.  I recall the entry of the Indian top tier into HRO three years' ago, and have to admit I was skeptical.  Not many people believed you could take broadscale HR services offshore and run them successfully, while saving money for clients at the same time.  However, times have really changed since then, with the Indian top-tier now competing aggressively for hybrid IT-BPO contracts. What's more, the Indian providers are very good at working out how to take on back office work remotely.  It's their focus - and eagerness - to take on ground-up processes, such as payroll, data management, document fulfillment, which is driving a breath of fresh air into the flagging HRO business.

A final word from India: moving beyond "old BPO"

As we discussed last week, BPO is rapidly evolving into "Global Services Provision". Most enterprises ventured into early BPO engagements to take advantage of the quick cost-savings on offer from employee remediation, using low-cost offshore labor on offer from outsourcing service providers. Many enterprises undertook BPO in times of financial distress, their priority centered on their year-end balance sheet and satisfying short-term shareholder demand, as opposed to long-term strategic thinking.

Finance and Accounting BPO continues its growth path

As we picked up on here a few weeks ago, the F&A BPO market has had a red hot 2007, and this growth is continuing into this year.   The market saw a 30% growth in expenditure, a 20% growth in total contracts, and new contract expenditure totaling close to $4bn in contract value.  So a record year and a critical mass is being reached.  The barriers to entry in this market are getting harder and we're getting a clearer picture of how this could play out.  So, what's driving this, and who are the key players?  Read my aticle in the new issue of FAOToday magazine.

HRO Redux: 8/10 buyers don't look back, while the vendors look ahead

Following our recent discussions surrounding the successes and challenges of the HR Outsourcing (HRO) industry, I was sent a recent study from Erik Samdahl at the Institute for Corporate Productivity, which canvassed the opinions of 231 senior HR executives, mainly from large organizations, and has some telling stats on the future direction of HRO, which I wanted to share and interpret with you. There are two key observations from this study that standout in my mind:

Join the BPO and Offshoring Best Practices Forum

Sign up now!

I am extending an invitation to HFS readers apply to join our new networking group on LinkedIn entitled the "BPO and Offshoring Best Practices Forum" - we already have 850 members signed up.  This is intended to be a forum for leading outsourcing executives to share their experiences, views, opinions, best practices and lessons learned in the world of business process outsourcing and offshoring.  You will also get a chance to participate in a "State of the BPO Industry" online survey next month.  And it's FREE.

 

Musings from abroad... dispatch #1

 

I'm currently on a three-week outsourcing excursion across France, UK, Belgium and then India... so I thought I'd entertain you all with some pictures and musings along the way.  Am currently enjoying the hospitality of a outsourcing provider which owns this rather charming estate... can you guess which provider it is?

BPO partnerships are opportunistic, rarely strategic

Having worked closely with both ICG Commerce and Genpact for the last few years, it was a positive step forward for the firms to announce a partnership, but I believe the companies should go a step further and merge.  Partnerships like this are normally opportunistic; they help the firms team up for broader finance/procurement customer bids, as they can be vulnerable when competing with Accenture and IBM, which have broadscale finance & accounting (F&A) and Procurement BPO solutions. 

Will the EDS acquisition spark a BPO feeding frenzy?

So HP acquired EDS.  Wow.  Biggest services news since HP acquired Compaq a week before 9/11?  In my opinion it is, anyway.

We discussed here in January the issue of consolidation among large outsourcing suppliers, and the general view was one that we would be unlikely to see acquisition among services firms that were similar in nature:

Outsourcers like to acquire firms that bring something new to the table to enhance their outsourcing offerings - for example new technologies, or a niche expertise that gives them competitive advantage.  Too many large outsourcers are too similar... they overlap too much and a merger would often end up as an unprofitable exercise and result in a mass exodus of key talent.

Bored? Look no further

Clearly you have far too much time on your hands if you're spending time here, so here are more places to go to fill those vacant hours.  This is especially for all you sourcing consultants who went out of your way to vote for yourselves as the "top place to go to get balanced advice on outsourcing" - c'mon chaps get real -:)

IBM vs. Tata: Who's More American? - Businessweek's Steve Hamm raises some incisive points, namely, TCS, India's largest tech-services company, collected 51% of its revenues in North America last quarter, while 65% of IBM's were overseas.   Builds upon some of the issues we discussed here last year;

HP/EDS redux

I know several of you are hounding me for my views here... we've put out a couple of pieces on this today at AMR - check out Bruce Richardson's blog where he raises the discussion. 

I have to confess this one came completely out of left-field while I was traveling, but does tally well with HP's focus on bundled BPO.  All-in-all, these are my key takeaways from this eventful day:

No-one saw this one coming, most of us were expecting one of the Indian providers merging with EDS.  This now raises the possibility of further mergers in services, even though this was looking unlikely until recently.  The incumbent Western providers need scale and depth to compete effectively with the lower-cost Indian firms, and we could see a response from one of the other top tier firms to swallow up one of the vulnerable services firms.

On the BPO side, this is a great move, with the merger filling both companies’ BPO portfolio gaps, most notably in finance and accounting (F&A) and HR processes.  As we discussed a few weeks' ago, BPO market leaders Accenture and IBM have already been aggressively pushing their combined portfolios of finance and accounting and HR BPO services, with increasing emphasis on bundling these services with their application outsourcing services.   HP is looking to follow suit, with the likes of Cap Gemini, Infosys, Wipro and TCS avidly observing how they can broaden their global BPO and IT services depth, scale and industry specialization.  Now HP has deep HR delivery expertise to draw on, which elevates its bundling capability, in addition to EDS's $1 billion call center outsourcing and global IT services business.

Culturally, this is definitely an odd one to fathom, but Mark Hurd has the track record and financial discipline to make this merger a success.  He also got a good valuation for the firm, so now was probably a good time to strike.

Interesting times... maybe we'll have some more days like this in the coming months?

Are we reaching an inflection point of business globalization?

I can't help feeling we are entering into a critical phase of business globalization, due to a convergence of factors.   We have seen these global dynamics in play for the last 30 years, but we are now in an economy where today's CEOs are aware they need the tools at their disposal to become truly integrated global enterprises.

I was privileged to have a preview of IBM's new study of 1100 CEOs this week at its analyst event in New York, and, while the findings are under embargo until next Tuesday's public release, I can say they reinforced one thing for me:  the vast majority of today's CEOs recognize the need for change, and are more prepared than ever to be bold and adopt measures that can drive rapid change through their organization.   So why is now different from that of 5 years' ago, or 25 years' ago?

HROWorld 2008: An industry re-inventing itself

Braving the annual industry HRO schmooze fest this year, I realized I was emulating Roger Federer’s extraordinary Wimbledon run by making it to my fifth-consecutive show.  Only an elite few have made all six – at least I can’t claim that honor -:)

From the moment I stepped into Naomi Bloom’s Brazen Hussies event on Tuesday night and was ordered to eat a heavily-garlicked vol-au-vent with the instruction “we’ve all had one, and so should you”, I knew something interesting was in the air this year.

For starters, all the industry big-guns were there; the leading HRO providers with all had their head honchos; the sourcing advisors; both SAP's and Oracle's BPO teams espousing the virtues of outsourcing on their ERP platforms; every staffing, benefits, talent management, data-something-or-other firm you’d never heard of; and even a few mercenary analysts dotted around the place.  We even had a new double-act to entertain us – the Elliot and Richard show, moderated by the vivacious and cabalistic Jay Whitehead.  This was one networking event when you just had to be there.

So, in true HROWorld tradition, I slammed myself with 20 back-to-back meetings over the two days, supplemented with a constant supply of stale coffee and a constant stream of sales literature I will cherish for a long time (ahem). 

My overall impression of the state of HRO is one of re-engineering to get this right.  This was the resounding message I got from several discussions with the market-makers in this industry. OK, we’ve had a few non-starters recently, but let’s emphasize these were projects that were cancelled before any implementation work had taken place, and in several cases, the contract had just never quite made it to fruition.  This doesn’t imply that HRO is failing; it implies that some businesses have made strategic decisions that now isn’t the right time to undergo open-heart HR surgery on themselves.  And do you blame some of these firms, when the bottom has fallen out of their industry and they might just have some other urgent priorities to rectify?

I wrote a year ago that the industry crystallized around the Convergys/J&J deal, and I was right.  What I liked about this show was the serious discussion on what works in HRO versus what doesn’t.  There was a refreshing honesty from almost everyone regarding the steps suppliers and buyers need to take to make this work…and so much less hype.  In fact we had so little hype, we could have used some.  Most of the suppliers are seriously focusing on what they are good at, and crafting HRO solutions based on their core strengths.  The need for standards and common service levels was discussed at length, with several ongoing initiatives in the industry currently focused on the joint-development of common HR standards and technologies that enable a more robust, repeatable HR delivery model. 

There was universal recognition that HRO works when solutions are crafted from the bottom-up, with services added incrementally and HR leaders having more time to develop successful governance practices, as opposed to some of these massive end-to-end “big-bang” deployments, that have often resulted in a misalignment of expectations and delivery.  This isn’t failure or disaster; it’s a 9 year-old industry testing the boundaries of what works - and what doesn’t.  I’ve been at pains recently to point-out that 97% of HRO deals have succeeded – and by succeeded, I emphasize that they are plugging away to get this right.

Let’s be brutally honest here, this is business process outsourcing – and this is a tough complex business, where things can only go wrong.  You really cannot judge the “success” of any major outsourcing engagement until it’s at least 3 years’ along and transition has been completed.  The day of the billion-dollar mega-HRO deal may be over for now, but take some time to look at the plethora of these “bottom-up” engagements taking place, where companies like ADP and Ceridian are racking up their HRO clientele at double-digit growth rates; look at Hewitt’s re-focused strategy on centering its core benefits outsourcing business as the kernel of its HRO delivery model; and look at Accenture's and IBM’s continuing efforts to optimize their global HRO engagement models, with HR service-delivery centers employing thousands of service personnel across several global locations. The seeds of this industry have been sewn, and we’ve had our reality check.  Now it’s time to move on and watch some great companies make this thing work.

Is the sub-prime lending crisis placing outsourcing engagements on the backburner, or providing an impetus to proceed faster?

UBS has shelved their planned HRO engagement with ACS and IBM as a result of its issues with the sub-prime lending crisis, the economy and their internal business uncertainty.  Like the recent Starbucks cancellation of their HRO engagement, plans have been waylaid to progress into a major HRO implementation due to changes in the business, as opposed to any operational issues.

What concerns me is the level of short-term-ism that some companies are currently adopting, with their looking only at the next quarter, as opposed to the longer-term picture.  I do believe this crisis will provide the outsourcing industry with a mixed-bag of opportunities, with some firms viewing the bigger picture and moving more aggressively into outsourcing initiatives, and others, like UBS, deferring decisions over long-term initiatives such as HRO, as they monitor the current economic situation and figure out their survival tactics.  Surely this is a perfect time to embrace changes to your business that will drive lower operating costs and new ways of doing things?  I'd be interested in your views....

Hewlett-Packard warms to bundled BPO/ITO

I spent some time at HP's industry analyst event in Boston today, and was surprised to hear its leadership openly embracing BPO as one of the company's strategic initiatives. Having witnessed the firm quietly picking up several large - and complex - BPO deals over the last 3 years, I have been disappointed that CEO Mark Hurd has, until now, chosen to talk up other product lines of his company - i.e. its infrastructure and printer businesses, leaving its promising BPO service line to take a backseat.  Meanwhile, several of HP's services competitors have been aggressively touting BPO as a major strategic arm for their businesses, despite the fact their BPO market presence is far inferior to that of HP's.

I will be writing a lot more about bundled outsourcing solutions in the coming months, as I firmly believe the future of outsourcing lies in outsourcing vendors' abilities to deliver hybrid business process and IT solutions in a managed services model - either under a single vendor, or under a well-governed combination of best-of-breed players.  HP's new outsourcing client, Molson Coors,is a bundled F&A, HR and IT engagement, which can make sense for many mid-size firms of a similar size, where having a single throat to choke, combined with the fact that their provider is transforming business processes in tandem with their corresponding business applications, can prove to be the right way to go.  However, I do emphasize the "can" here, as it's really all about how effectively buyers govern their vendor relationships, and understanding what works best for them.  Again, it's a question - in every instance - of Horses for Courses....

March madness: little advisors, Starbucks redux, F&A is bubbling back... and EDS gets active

So what was the month of March all about?

Little outsourcing advisors.  The outsourcing advisor debate continued on Deal Architect.  We opened the debate here where we discussed the plethora of small boutique outsourcing advisors that continue to be influential advising on outsourcing engagements.  We also kicked off a heated discussion thread when we discussed what enterprises should look for in an advisor.  Vinnie makes some interesting comments on why many firms find advantages with the smaller players, especially when established advisors can suffer from Stockholm Syndrome and refrain from aggressive negotiation tactics with large vendors.  Bottom-line, it's "Horses for Courses" when enterprises decide what's best for them... now where is that recurring theme from again?

Starbucks redux.  Returning CEO Howard Schultz made a quick decision to perform a U-turn on the retailer's HR Outsourcing (HRO) engagement with Convergys, which got debated here.  HRO has proved too much of a distraction for the firm’s management and staff, as the firm goes through a major restructuring to improve its offering to its customers, close some US stores and slow down opening new ones.  With the contract only eight months old, you cannot cite operational issues as a prime reason for this reversal of strategy.  As only Convergys was involved in the initial blue-print deployment work, both parties can exit the agreement before any serious implementation efforts have started. With the press trying to find flaws in the HRO model, I have been at pains to point out that only a small handful of HRO deployments (3%) have actually been terminated.  While comprehensive HRO deals may be under continual scrutiny, the demand for smaller scope HRO solutions in transactional areas is still healthy, with ADP announcing it is servicing payroll for 100,000 of Sodexo's employees.  The fifth annual HROWorld show this year should be interesting... and yes, I will be there.

Finance & Accounting (F&A) Outsourcing is bubbling again.  There are a number of major F&A BPO pursuits well underway at the moment, with the market showing strong signs of a pick up this year after a slowdown in the latter half of 2007.  Watch-out for my upcoming report on this market in May.  My old friend Clarence Schmitz, who runs F&A BPO specialist Outsourcing Partners International, has also been busy expanding his company's footprint.  Only a week after he announced his firm had opened a new F&A service center in Gurgaon (New Delhi), I was invited to the opening of their new 280,000 sq foot facility in Bangalore in May.  OPI now boasts three facilities in India (their other center is in Kochi),  in addition to its Central European center in Sofia, Bulgaria.  And if you ever wanted some excellent - and low-cost - skiing, don't discount Bulgaria...

EDS is back onboard the public sector gravy train. It's been an interesting few weeks for EDS, with its contact center outsourcing and government businesses.  No sooner had it announced its joint initiative with Microsoft to develop its Dynamics CRM solutions for its call center business, that it announced it had been named one of the preferred suppliers to the General Services Administration's $2.5 bn Indefinite Delivery/Indefinite Quantity contact center services contract.  This comes hot on the heals of a mega $1.3 bn contract with the Singapore government's iDA to provide desktop services across Singapore 74 public agencies both domestically and worldwide.  Having lived and worked in Singapore, I can personally attest that the country is a true pioneer in developing Internet-enabled government services for its citizens. With EDS' recent initiatives to restructure its SAP services practice and its renewed focus on developing its legacy integration services, are we looking at a new era for the Plano TX firm?  My view is it needs to fill the F&A BPO gap in its delivery portfolio and it will have a completing array of BPO and IT services.  Don't bet against an acquisition this year to remedy this.  Drop me an email if you want to speculate further...

And more from Blogsphere in March....